Monday, 24 December 2018

Variation on a Theme: The Official Starships Collection Issues 138 and 139


Just when you think you’ve had enough Miranda Class variants another one turns up.

Yep, the most recent editions of the Official Starships Collection from Eaglemoss have brought fans a fourth iteration of the USS Reliant design with the USS Lantree from The Next Generation’s Unnatural Selection

The observant Trekkie will know that the only visual difference between the Reliant and the Lantree is the missing weapons rollbar from the 1988 appearance due to faulty electrics. For those collecting the series of ship replicas there’s a bit more to it.

The Lantree for one has gone with the slightly larger scale established with the Saratoga and used again on the Bozeman. Now the Reliant set the bar for Federation aztec paintwork back in issue 11 and since then there have been improvements. Given the larger surface area to play with here, the paint job gets more space to work in and avoids cluttering the ship; much cleaner to appreciate if you will!

The top of the saucer is ornamented with two reaction control thrusters in yellow plus the port and starboard running lights. Eaglemoss have also managed to pick out the three paired phaser banks which sit between the name and ship number which is also a significant improvement thanks to the ever so slightly larger scale. 

Worth a mention is the decalling on this upper surface with the red striping curving

almost perfectly with the hull panel lines and also to the very evenly printed registry with a clear red outer border - however that too is a little out of kilter with the text.

Eaglemoss have installed the Starfleet pennant on top of each of the photon torpedo launchers with mechanical detail visible behind the exit points. That darker grey recessed feature is repeated on the two larger sensor-like platforms that stretch to the rear of the Lantree. There's not significant tech here but enough to give a good impression with the larger elements on screen replicated onto the model. It's ok but the paint does seem a tad heavy and is overriding some of the less prominent components in these parts of the hull.

Rear and centre is the top of the warp core painted up in grey and blue tones. There is some fine fanned detail on this element of the craft which is carried over onto the underside.

I'm quite impressed with the bridge module on this one too with the Lantree carrying the dark grey stripe around the piece plus window detail and even a very small "Lantree" across the back of it.

The upper section of the ship is metal cast and around the lip of the saucer we have a series of white porthole "lights" which extend back to the sides of the engineering block. To the rear there are also the "1" and "2" shuttle bays as well as a rather poorly detailed impulse engine unit between the two auxiliary craft hatches. The hull panelling is just evident around the two painted red exhausts but in comparison to the rest of the ship it's missing the aztec patterning and certainly a degree of definition.

Flipping over, the plastic underside insert does a great job of continuing the aztec paint pattern right across the bottom surface of the Lantree. The striping detail around the middle is notably better lined up to the hull panel lines although the ship registry is still a little off in regards to the placement of the red bordering on the black numbers and letters. The definition on the panel lines is as good as on the top if not slightly better in my opinion. The grooves seem deeper and there's more going on down there for another thing. 

The triple phaser banks are painted up yellow and the windows near to the senor dome are painted up perfectly even though they are raised against the flat surface of the hull. The mechanics to the rear do show more detail than those on the metallic upper section and are painted in the same dark grey colour suggesting it might be the material used to make each half which is causing the different levels of quality in the finishing details. Indeed, both within the dark grey section and to either side on the ventral portion of the Lantree there are more hull tech pieces than anywhere else on the ship's surface.

Finally we come to the engines and unfortunately they're not quite parallel on the one I received. The plastic support struts start from the top of the hull, betraying that the rollbar from the Reliant has been unceremoniously cut off. It almost makes the ship look structurally unsound however the pylons are quite firm and marked up with the Starfleet pennant on both sides. The warp engines themselves are flimsy especially right at the back with finishing ship details again on either side of the fin shaped back section.

What isn't obvious straight away is that the warp field grilles here are translucent because the colouring is the darkest it's been on any Starfleet vessel. The fit together of the plastic nacelles and their coloured interior sections is well executed and there no glaring gaps or sprue joins marking the surface - it's a pretty seamless job in fact.

Stand sit for the Lantree is identical to its forebears in the series with the stand sliding over the rear and across the darker grey hull sections. It's a lot more secure fit than the Reliant but would still give me slight cause for concern if the unit it was standing on was knocked.

The issue 138 magazine recounts the extended lifespan of the Miranda Class into the 24th Century as well as the Lantree's mission as viewed in Unnatural Selection from The Next Generation. Creating the USS Lantree skips back to the design and build for the Reliant before divulging the reasons for the changes in the ship for its first appearance alongside the Enterprise-D before spending the remaining pages discussing the ups and more numerous downs from season two of The Next Generation. Lots of bits covered in here such as the infamous writers' strike, the replacement of Doctor Crusher and the arrival of the Borg. A good overview and introduction to the year but there are more substantial sources to go to after this.

Ok. On to issue 139 and what at first I nearly mistook for a 1980's GI Joe toy given the grey, green and black colour scheme. This one's the Vaadwaur Fighter from Voyager's sixth season highlight Dragon's Teeth.

The design of the fighter is somewhat blocky with the feel of a catamaran from the apparent twin-hull look. With two sections of the hull jutting out ahead of the cockpit, the single seat ship has an aggressive stance but with a very basic finish to it.

The paintwork of green, dark grey and light grey is very bold and flat with three basic elements covering the whole craft. The metal upper hull does carry some grille work and service details yet the definition of panelling is left to the way in which the hull is coloured. Eaglemoss have done some weathering on these grated sections and also on the back around the triple engine set up however it looks more forced and fake because it is limited to tiny areas of the craft leaving the remainder looking absolutely showroom perfect. If this was going to receive some aging then the whole ship needed it not just specific pieces as it looks like a toy more than a Star Trek vessel.

The big engine detail in the centre is again very clean with some smaller detailing indicating power channels of some kind.  It's one piece that does draw the eye to it and the look on the outside even goes to show how it links to the three engine exhausts to the back.What you can say is that this fighter has very well defined panelling and colouring with every panel almost having its own colour block. It's a striking paint scheme and not something we see employed on many ships from the franchise. 

At the front Eaglemoss have blacked out the cockpit and slung two plastic cannons onto the underside. Again there's a little bit of surface detail on the barrels of these weapons but it's nothing exceptional suggesting this really was a one off craft that was barely going to be seen. 

To the back we have the three engine exhausts with that off-putting blackened weathering effect. It looks terribly fake and out of place and lining it up against the weathering on something like the USS Kelvin would really show how scrappy a job this has been. The exhausts themselves are spotted out very precisely in orange and keep the colour here within the centre circles of the engines. Plus point on the engines too is that the central one isn't a straight mirror left/right with an individual set of markings on the port. Nice touch.

The underside of plastic continues the uninspiring block colouring along both sides of the hull with some deeper grilled action just ahead of the lighter grey engine units. Not much to go on here again aside from the fact that the Vaadwaur fighter looks far newer than it has any right to be.

Connected into the plastic underside insert are two pairs of pylons to support the warp engines protruding from either side of the craft.Once more there's an overly blackened weathering effect at the leading edge before opening out into the rather unusual warp engine design.

These three-quarter circumference tubes continue the blocky paint pattern from the main hull but also allow full view of the centre of the engines which in this case are translucent orange "torpedoes". It's a bold design move and likely a mare to recreate on the model especially since you can see the fixing points through the orange plastic which does ruin the effect a little.

The whole base plate of the Vaadwaur Fighter might be in plastic but it is virtually identical in detailing to the upper side. The green stripe mirrors the dorsal pattern, enclosed with a series of the darker grey panelling. The alignment of these segments on the whole ship is, for Eaglemoss, surprisingly accurate. I'm not knocking them but their attempts to line panels to colours - or windows - has left something to the imagination but on larger pieces we seem to have it nailed to perfection, the fighter being a great example.

Bizarrely the colours on the magazine cover are totally different to the model with the green stripes more yellow and the greys about five shades lighter than they appear on the accompanying fighter.

Problem is that the magazine images don't help decide what the correct colour scheme is with only new CG and one shot of the hangar from Dragon's Teeth as evidence. This actually does show how little these ships were utilised since the available source material you would hope to see alongside the craft is AWOL. The magazine also betrays a sense of the over-weathering on certain points plus the lack of "gap" under the engine arms that stretch out from the central unit. Probably impossible to include due to the scale but one for note nevertheless.

I loved reading through the mag with this one because of my love for the episode itself and Eaglemoss have delivered on that front. Giving a full overview of the ship capabilities plus a brief summary of the episode and Vaadwaur history, it's a good comprehensive take on the sixth season story.

Designing the Vaadwaur City and Fighter is brilliant, giving a full 360 view on the episode from story to the visual concepts. The city is one of Voyager's great shots as is the destruction sequence of the buildings at the very start. This gives a good look into how this became quite an expensive show given the scope of the narrative.

Six pages of visual effects talks through the advances of the sixth year of Voyager with notable highlights of course including Dragon's Teeth and One Small Step which included creating the Ares IV capsule. 

This month's arrivals are slightly underwhelming. We have a redress of a classic and then a one-ep blink and miss. Of the two I'd prefer to say I love the Vaadwaur Fighter but the detailing on the Lantree comes to another level and is a nice one to complete the Miranda variant mini-collection.

Next month's pairing sees the Starfleet Tug featured in Deep Space Nine take on the Vulcan T'Pau ship from The Next Generation's Unification.

Vaadwaur or Lantree for this month's stronger arrival? Have these two been done too late or should they have been included at all?


Live on YouTube
Like our page on Facebook 
Follow us on Twitter

Add us on Tumblr