Wednesday, 4 November 2015

Degrees Kelvin: The Fifth Starships Collection Special



Still keeping to the JJ-verse, the latest special brings the aging USS Kelvin to fans shelving units.

Delivered in its larger "specials" box and foam packaged, the Kelvin is a lot better than I expected. We had been privy to some crisp images from Ben Robinson during the production process but to actually see her is something else.


Well, once it arrived that is because for some reason subscribers had to wait for it to arrive with their issue 58 and 59 deliveries while shop-buying collectors could buy it over a week before.

So to this larger model and the first thing that struck me was that Eaglemoss have weathered the hull - something we just don't see enough of in this series but very applicable to what is supposed to be an old starship.

OK, closer look time so out of the box and onto her stand. It's a rear-saucer fit which is fairly central to the point of gravity so no chance of a planet-fall unless you're an unstable hand with a duster. The clear clip fit into the base is pretty decent too - much better than the Defiant which finally arrived this week. In that case I had to shave a few milimetres off the front of the post to get it into the base. With the Kelvin it's a straight slot-in, no issues and she does display well.

Approximately the same length as the JJ-verse Enterprise, the Kelvin has a lot more detail and looks a lot more complete than the flagship. Yes, the Enterprise was a newer ship but there was a lot of finishing detail missing from that second special which let it down. Here we have the aztec pattern on the hull along with that exemplary weathering effect which lifts the whole model and makes it appear to be as old as it was intended. She's certainly not clean and Eaglemoss have gone to a decent bit of trouble to work in the dirt and grime collected over years of service. Emblazoned on the panelling is the ship's registry in two places - the rear slightly off-centred due to the location of the attached secondary hull and more blatantly the name and number right across the front of the hull. The lines are pretty crisp and does go against the "worn" effect of the rest of the ship. In fact the registry on the magazine cover even has some weathering applied.

The saucer itself is top side metal and bottom plastic. Fairly sturdy all-round and pleasing to see that the detail carries over both surfaces. One thing though - there's missing striping and windows around that saucer edge and a conspicuous lack of RCS thrusters too which is odd seeing as they are included on much smaller ships from the regular issues. The registry too is edged in blue rather than the red which we saw in the movie. Definitely something odd going on here. I also spotted one on Facebook with a terrible join between the two sections and while mine is nowhere near as awful there's still a tiny bit of the plastic section which doesn't sit flush with the upper hull. Not a bit grumble but you do notice it!

The central bridge unit looks pretty basic against the rest of the upper hull with a yellowed out viewscreen and top "blip". The top of the saucer does also bear the huge ship name and registry which must be the biggest in Star Trek history hands down. As to actual surface detail it's sparce to say the least with only a few hatches and phaser emplacements both on the top and bottom. That underside does have a central sensor dome which, in maybe the same respect as the bridge, does seem like it was added, hurriedly, later.

To the secondary hull attached to the top of the saucer and still carrying the aztec paint scheme. They're also managed to add in a couple of red-edged docking ports, windows and more of that dirty weathering. The join between the two halves is fairly evident but on mine the fit is spot on, Perhaps the issue here is more with the limited detail on the deflector dish which is translucent all-blue and does look a bit out of place against the rest of the "aged" Kelvin. The shuttlebay at the rear of the engineering hull does appear to be a separate piece. While not sectioned out it does stand out from the rest of the structure effectively.

Finally there's the single warp engine slung on the underside of the saucer. Longer than the engineering section, it's capped with a clear plastic bussard collector marked out with a yellow and grey cap. Now looking to the magazine this doesn't look anything like the "real" thing so why this scheme was chosen was a mystery to me. At the rear the exhaust point is tipped with another blue plastic piece recessed into the nacelle. I'm not sure it looks quite right but since it's buried inside the nacelle housing you don't see it that clearly. It's also imprinted with a large ship registry which has been crisply applied to either side of the housing. It's actually larger than  we've seen on previous Starfleet vessels and unusually in the middle of the nacelle rather than being at the end. 


The magazine has a few more pages this time but is split into just two sections; ship profile and design. The former takes a mere three paragraphs which allows the remaining pages to be dedicated to the look of the Kelvin. Brilliant choice to do so too because we cover everything to do with its evolution and also its significance at being the first starship to be seen in the rebooted universe. Problem is that the images in these pages show just how limited the model is in terms of its detailing and aging. I suppose we have to understand that there are boundaries to what can be achieved given the retail price. 

The magazine's coverage of the design is extensive in both its narrative and the images we're given are superb, illustrating every step of the creative process, even back to when the Kelvin was the Iowa. Interesting point here that the shuttlebay, the underside sensor dome and the bussard collector get special attention and by default shows that Eaglemoss didn't quite get these three key features spot on. 


The magazine also explores the destruction of the Kelvin in that fantastic opening sequence. The way in which ILM performed the gradual degradation of the cruiser as she took fire from the Narada introduced them to a new process and gave viewers one of the most memorable scenes in the movie and one that promised so much from the reimagining of the franchise.

The Kelvin special is one that we've been titillated with for some time. The ship itself isn't quite accurate and in terms of quality against the other four specials I'd say it's comfortably better than the JJ-Enterprise but not quite up to the D-4, Vengeance or Deep Space Nine. The scale does mean it can be presented with more detail but those blips do mean it doesn't quite hit the mark for me although it's still a nice ship if a little plain - which definitely isn't helped with all those missing saucer details at the least.


Google Images
The next special is likely/rumoured to be the NX-01 refit that was never actually seen on screen but was designed for that "what if" scenario. Looking forward to that since the original NX-01 is still one of the best models - if not the best - of the entire series and has held that esteemed crown since issue four.

Fan of the USS Kelvin special or was it less than spectacular?


Live on YouTube
Like our page on Facebook 
Follow us on Twitter
+1 us on Google+
Add us on Tumblr
Add to to conversation on Star Trek: Risa

Monday, 2 November 2015

Just to Recap - Here's the Headline


How am I feeling right now?

A bit shocked, surprised and very, very, very excited. Monday November 2nd 2015 has now joined the ranks of September 8th 1966 and September 28th 1987 in Star Trek lore because today it was announced that the show we love will be back on our screens in January 2017 courtesy of CBS and their All Access service. It's news we have been waiting a long time to hear and with the 50th anniversary around the corner I have to admit I was expecting us to hear something in 2016 rather than now. Still just can't believe it's going to happen!!!

I did breath a sigh of relief too because it more than likely means it won't be Captain Worf or Captain Sulu but it could be Uncharted which we know was pitched to CBS. Of course Beyond,  which is in no way linked to the series, will garner even more attention ahead of the 2017 show release which won't be a bad thing but it's just crazy to think that there is going to be new, televised Star Trek 12 years after it left our screens.

What do we know besides the launch date? Very little but that's to be expected since we're only having the fact Star Trek is returning announced. We also know that Alex Kurtzman is producing which suggests were going to see a series more action-orientated than before and may well take more nods from the JJ-verse style than Roddenberry's vision. I know the internet is already alight with 'it must have this' and 'they must do that' but, frankly, they can do what the hell they want with the franchise so prepare yourselves right now that you might not be completely happy with the results.

As for cast, concept, ship, aliens and the rest we know precisely zero. In fact we know  little more when it comes to Beyond which will be with us in a shade over seven months. But there's so much energy around this announcement that no one's really thinking about the finer points right now because we have at least confirmation that there will be new Star Trek on our TVs once a week.

We will be seeking out new life and new civilisations which suggests something going back to the roots of both The Original Series and The Next Generation so we could even get an Enterprise. Will it be in the future decades after Voyager?  Will it even be set in the Prime Universe?  Could it be set parallel to the action of the movies not dissimilar to Agents of SHIELD and the Marvel movies?  Can you imagine how incredible the visuals are going to look? Please let these characters actually have personalities that develop!!!

Who knows at this point what will arrive in 2017 because we don't even have confirmation of a script and there's no casting. Who they get to be involved will be vigorously scrutinised by every single fan and you just have the feeling that the next few months will be seething with Star Trek news either cinematic or televisual.

Behind the camera we have confirmed that Kurtzman acting as exec with Heather Kadin producing with him but apparently reporting up to Alex. Kurtzman's credits are eminently bankable having co-written two Star Trek movies plus Transformers, its sequel Revenge of the Fallen plus  The Amazing Spiderman 2. What strikes me is that while eminently bankable these aren't films that have been critically well-received or been that highly regarded for their scripts. I would also question whether he knows the franchise intimately as is sugested by the press release since the two previous Star Trek reboot movies have veered considerably from their inspiration.

Heather Kadin is an unknown quantity to me as I've not seen any of her work but she is directly linked with Kurtzman having worked with him on Scorpion, Sleepy Hollow and Limitless. What she will bring to the franchise I'm not really sure aside from some more fresh blood and a new set of eyes to work out the details. 

How we'll get to see it in the UK hasn't been revealed. In the US it will be first run on CBS All Access which costs $5.99 per week so we could see it land on something like Netflix prior to the seasonal box set release. The pilot will be shown on the main CBS network before going to the subscription service for the remainder of its run. In fact it will be the first new series to be shown in this manner by CBS.

The internet fury certainly kicked off quickly with over 49,000 tweets 109,000 tweets (amended 3/11/15) on the subject and key forums being flooded with the same story plus vehement analysis of the release. Star Trek fans certainly have concrete opinions and a series from the same stable that brought us the reboot is going to be controversial before the first frame has even been shot. Love it or hate it, Star Trek is back where it belongs on the small screen and it will undoubtedly divide the fanbase. But this is a different time, a new era in the franchise and I am looking forward to seeing how a new show is tackled differently to a reboot movie series or how it works to respect its heritage.

Starting counting down to January 2017 now because the news is going to be coming thick and fast now we have a launch date. Will there be a 26 episode season? Will we be on a Federation ship? Are they going to bring back the Borg? Will we see any significant cameos or is it all going JJ-verse? 

Tons of questions but I do think the fanbase can be incredibly harsh and at times go completely against IDIC if we don't like one single element but hey, it's an opinion right? For some people they will have already dismissed the show due to its announced production credits but I would rather wait and see what makes it to the screen. Could it kill Star Trek? Who knows right now because I think we're all still reeling from the fact that someone has faith to try it again. My mind is definitely swirling with a billion Star Trek thoughts that I need to sift through but let's be sure to give it a chance please and fans of the new show should be welcomed into the fold just as much as anyone who is passionate about the Roddenberry originals.

Hey, it could even become the biggest TV phenomenon of the 21st Century - now there's a thought....

Header image taken from startrek.com press release. All other images from Google Images

What do you think? If this isn't the biggest Star Trek news since the reboot was announced!!!

Live on YouTube
Like our page on Facebook 
Follow us on Twitter
+1 us on Google+
Add us on Tumblr
Add to to conversation on Star Trek: Risa

All Dressed Up: Star Trek Costumes


Just go and buy this now.

If I was keeping this review simple and straightforward that's exactly what it would say. In fact just open another tab while you're reading this and order a copy.  Go on. Yep,  that's it....

And why am I exhibiting signs of total over excitement towards this book?  Because it's flippin' brilliant. That's why. 

Since it's announcement early in the year I've been looking forward to seeing just how this was going to be pulled off.  Would it be another childlike book with idiotic annotations and minimal text that any fan of any age or knowledge level would feel patronised by?  Not at all.  In fact quite the opposite.

For about four hours on Saturday I was glued to this book,  reading every word and taking in every picture,  sketch and note. Truly this is a one of a kind book that will never be repeated and is something never seem before in print.

It's a heavy book in both weight and price but the finished product more than justifies both in my humble opinion with its informative text and stunning colour images packing out every single page in this hardback product.

Written and extensively researched by Paula M Block and Terry J Erdmann,  Star Trek Costumes is the first and last word on the clothes that helped realise the vision of the Final Frontier.  If you're familiar with their work,  the pair were responsible for the stunning 365 books on The Original Series and The Next Generation, Star Trek 101 as well as putting together one of the best Star Trek series reference guides ever, the Deep Space Nine Companion.

Starting out with The Original Series, readers get an intricate look at everything from Andrea's infamous jumpsuit through to the varying materials of the main cast uniforms, this has everything and all shades (pun intended) in between. The best thing is that it's not just a picture and some text about what it's made from - there are actual first hand stories, notes on how changes were made, how Theiss titilated, how items were reused and what inspired some of the most incredible costumes to have hit the technicolour screen. Not just pictures but original sketches as yet unchanged for the screen and first hand accounts of what wearing the items was actually like.

From there the tone certainly subdues with the greys of The Motion Picture and how the wardrobe from the movie was resurrected and again, reused with some clever colouring for the second movie and beyond. The writers have packed this to bursting point allowing us insight into why Khan's costume appears as it does and what was used to give it a "worn" look, what led to the civilian oufits for The Search for Spock and The Voyage Home and even how Sybok was attired for The Final Frontier.

But it's not just a journey through history but a trek through the work of several individuals who have picked up the torch from their predecessor and made their own indelible mark on the Star Trek universe. It might be Robert Fletcher's legendary monster maroon "off colour" movie uniforms or Durinda Rice Wood's original Borg bitsa costumes but each one has left something that each of us will instantly recognise and remember with fondness. 

Interestingly The Next Generation receives a three-way split dependent on the wardrobe boss in charge at the time. Theiss' work is purely the first season and explains more than the troubling effect of stretching spandex while Durinda Rice Wood in season two got to re-work Troi's severe appearance  as well as introduce the Borg to the world. However her successor, Bob Blackman, took over the reins from season three right through to the demise of Enterprise in 2005. While he didn't touch any of the movies with the exception of Generations and the odd dress uniform, Blackman has probably had the biggest impact on the clothes of the 24th Century more than anyone else.


There is significant space given over to the last five years of The Next Generation as well as individual sections on each of the movies (with their own designer) but I was just a little disappointed that Deep Space Nine, Voyager and Enterprise were clumped together into one bite rather than each having their own section. There's still a lot covered in the pages but as a Niner I would have loved to have seen much more on the variety of alien races that dropped in and out as well as the main and secondary casts.

The other thing that niggles are the few terrible typos that should have been picked up - Dax and Jadzia's wedding? That image NOT being Kira's seventh season colonel's uniform and an odd one noting a communicator as a phaser. Icky errors that do take a little bit of the edge away from what is otherwise a perfect Star Trek reference book and one that is 200% essential to any Star Trek fan's library. Even the internet does not do justice to this under-appreciated topic within the franchise and certainly the unsung heroes who have slaved away in the hours of the night to sew up a costume or finish a crucial design.


Importantly Star Trek Costumes closes out with a section on the two rebooted movies. I did skip to the end looking for any teasers of Beyond but I was out of luck. What we get with the 2009 movie and Into Darkness is fairly standard since there haven't been a massive range of characters. There's the requisite look at the nicely re-envisaged classic uniforms which did receive a minor twist for the sequel as well as Nero's Romulans, the image in black of Cumberbatch's Khan and certainly the one which stopped me flicking back through the book - the helmeted, armoured Klingons. Their coverage in both the sections regarding the reboot movies is excellent and certainly the highlight of that later part of the book even if you're not a keen follower of the reboot.

Block and Erdmann have produced a fantastic read here and one that fans will be looking over for years. Everything about it oozes quality and makes this a no-brainer purchase. Having a few more pages on some of the most bizarre and one-off costumes might have been the only thing that they could have added but you can't question the level of detail or research that has gone into producing the book as it stands. Quite simply one of the best Star Trek reference books for a while.

You can order the Star Trek Costumes book now from Titan Books HERE priced £35.00 ISBN 9781783299676.


Live on YouTube
Like our page on Facebook 
Follow us on Twitter
+1 us on Google+
Add us on Tumblr
Add to to conversation on Star Trek: Risa

Saturday, 31 October 2015

30 Days of Trek - Bonus Round!


As promised, here's my little added extra to round out October.

I'll keep it simple today because I'm actually handing over control to you guys today, the readers!

So first off, thanks to everyone who has even attempted a single question over the last month and to those of you that have managed to keep up with all 30, well done and thanks for coming along. I hope you've enjoyed it and maybe found out a couple of things about Star Trek too. I thought I was insane for attempting this but somehow it's worked.

Which brings us to this Ask Me Anything. Here's how we're going to work this. In the comments section just post up your question and I'll answer it. I'm also opening this up to everyone who has followed the #30daysoftrek to answer the questions posted so you might get some interesting answers.

Normal service on Some Kind of Star Trek will be resumed this week. I have a chunk of reviews and other assorted bits coming up which I hope you will enjoy.

Check back on all the previous questions HERE.

Live on YouTube
Like our page on Facebook 
Follow us on Twitter
+1 us on Google+
Add us on Tumblr
Add to to conversation on Star Trek: Risa

Friday, 30 October 2015

30 Days of Trek - Day Thirty


...But alas all good things must come to an end.


Sniff, sniff. It's the last day and our final question for #30daysoftrek. Has it really been a month? Was I really stupid enough to attempt a question a day? Yes to both of those questions.



Which is why I wanted us to end on a high, a nice, easy question to end the challenge. We started with favourite episode so let's end on favourite series.

From the last month it might have become apparent that my favourite show is Deep Space Nine. Saying that, it wasn't until the third season that I finally "got" it. The first two years were decidedly average and, running as they were, alongside The Next Generation's sixth and seventh seasons, I didn't see it as major competition for my Star Trek affections.

The announcement of a new starship and that the Dominion would have an increased presence in the series certainly piqued my interest. For a brief period between the end of The Next Generation and Voyager, Deep Space Nine held its own and made massive improvements. It retained its darker overtones, the conflict that Voyager steered away from and embraced an incredibly character-driven story focus. That namely came from the stationary nature of Deep Space Nine itself and instead of providing a hindrance it meant that events could continue, there were consequences and genuine character development not only specific to themselves but in relation to each other and even recurring guests.

The arrival of Worf and the Klingons breaking from the Khitomer Accords were unexpected moments and I even thought it was a last gasp attempt to keep the show alive, potentially even doing it more harm than good. Instead it just added even more to the show and Deep Space Nine went from strength to strength giving us utter classics such as The Visitor, Trials and Tribble-ations, Children of Time, Call to Arms, Far Beyond the Stars, In the Pale Moonlight and Tacking into the Wind; episodes I would easily place in any "best of" listing. 

Through the inclusion of the three classic Klingons, those tribbles and the Mirror Universe, Deep Space Nine also became the series to draw the most (I felt) on its roots to The Original Series and acknowledge its history.

The final years may have been dominated by the Dominion War but it was much more than just a series of space battles. There were brilliantly written stories that explored the issues of war as well as expanding on the roles of the Bajorans, the influence of Gul Dukat, the exploration of the Klingons in more detail with the inclusion of Martok as well as Worf and a whole host of other twists and turns along the way. 

I'll always have a love for the franchise as a whole but for me Deep Space Nine was as good as it got; superb stories, layered and well-acted characters and ongoing developments that made it the most believable of Star Trek's incarnations.

So to you for the final time - what was your favourite show?


Check back on all the previous questions HERE. Remember that TOMORROW, October 31st, there will be an Ask Me Anything opportunity to end the challenge!

Live on YouTube
Like our page on Facebook 
Follow us on Twitter
+1 us on Google+
Add us on Tumblr
Add to to conversation on Star Trek: Risa

Thursday, 29 October 2015

30 Days of Trek - Day Twenty-Nine


Choices, choices, choices....

To be fair there are three seasons of The Original Series you can mine with pleasure for this and I have to admit that my selection is straight from those classic vaults - but not necessarily one you might immediately think about.

As we head through The Next Generation there aren't any that spring to mind since Picard was a stickler for regulation. The less said about Sisko's decisions in the final couple of years of Deep Space Nine the better but Janeway was again one for sticking to the rules as best as possible. Archer? Well he didn't have to worry about the Prime Directive - it hadn't been invented although there were a couple of occasions it should have been in use.

So to my choice and it could strike up a few comments. How about Kirk's decision to incite Mirror Spock to turn against the principles of the Terran Empire in Mirror, Mirror? Talk about non-interference, the captain manages to change the future irreparably as we see in Deep Space Nine thanks to goatee-toting Spock's rise to head of the Empire and disarmament of the fleet.

With only a few lines Kirk alters an entire timeline and effectively places humanity into slavery for nearly a century. Great move and a prime example of Kirk disobeying the Prime Directive because he thinks he knows better. Sadly it just provided the chance for another equally violent faction to seize power and carry on the "good work". I would expect this to be one place Captain Kirk is not the reverred hero! 

OK his heart is in the right place but there's no long term thought here - it's all about what is happening in front of his eyes on one ship at one point in the galaxy spanning Empire. I actually think this may be Kirk's Greatest Mistake Ever (second place not checking on Khan) and he even does what he does best which is stroll away to the next mission without a care. Bravo, captain, bravo. It is a bleak future but it does mean we get to see Intendent Kira lay waste to a whole series of episodes which many would suggest was actually well worth ignoring the Directive point blank.

So what was your favourite disregard for the Prime Directive and by who? Was it Kirk every time or did another character do it with more panache?

Check back on all the previous questions HERE and join me for OUR FINAL QUESTION tomorrow. Remember that on October 31st there will be an Ask Me Anything opportunity to end the challenge!

Live on YouTube
Like our page on Facebook 
Follow us on Twitter
+1 us on Google+
Add us on Tumblr
Add to to conversation on Star Trek: Risa

Wednesday, 28 October 2015

30 Days of Trek - Day Twenty-Eight


Let's go theoretical for our next challenge.

We've all got those favourite episodes, the ones we dislike and potentially some that just don't sit quite right with us.

So that's what today is all about - those episodes that faded to black and you thought "Hey, I would have done that another way..."

For this one I did have to cycle through a few options to find an episode that suited the question but there was no doubt when I did.

I went for The 37's from the first/second season of Voyager. Multiple times I've mentioned this story I've said how it fits much better at the end of that first year but one point still niggles. At the end of the episode Janeway and Chakotay find that no-one has decided to stay behind with the human colony they found. It's a gloriously positive end to the season (if you watch it in production order) showing how the Maquis and Starfleet crews have come together and committed to finding their way home.

But y'know I would have had a few of both crews stay behind. Why? Because one of the things that was evident early on was the chance to bring some conflict to Voyager between the two factions. That was quickly forgotten (grrr) but having a few decide that life on the starship wasn't for them would have kept that element alive and made things less than settling. 

Having everyone willing to follow Janeway after just a few months never sat easy with me and I think that mixing it up a little bit at the end of the season might have added in a pinch of spice for the second season and maybe added some weight behind the Jonas/Kazon story.

What change would you make and to which episode?

Check back on all the previous questions HERE and join me for question twenty-nine tomorrow. Remember that on October 31st there will be an Ask Me Anything opportunity to end the challenge!

Live on YouTube
Like our page on Facebook 
Follow us on Twitter
+1 us on Google+
Add us on Tumblr
Add to to conversation on Star Trek: Risa