2022 seems to be gaining a reputation as a most unforgiving year with news of another notable individual passing almost daily.
Already this year Star Trek alumni Nichelle Nichols and Louise Fletcher have headed to the Great Beyond now to be accompanied by Cheers star Kirstie Alley.
While the Boston bar-set TV series remains as the focal point of her career, her first movie appearance strikes more than a chord with Trek fans. Travel back 40 years to 1982 and you would find Alley donning the ears of Vulcan Saavik for The Wrath of Khan.
Saavik wasn't a one-hit posting as she would return in Star Trek III but notoriously this would see Robin Curtis take on the role. Curtis would then make a fleeting appearance in The Voyage Home with Saavik choosing to remain on Vulcan. Stories abound that money was at the centre of the non-return for Alley however of the two I would say that her performance is the stronger.
Is it just down to the fact that The Wrath of Khan is such a notable Star Trek film that Alley's Saavik is so widely well regarded? Are the reasons for her absence from Star Trek III also so well publicised that it has made an indelible mark on the franchise's history? Perhaps. How Alley would have taken the character had she reprised the role may well have been different in interpretation to Curtis although to understand the character beyond the screen it's well worth diving into the novelisations of II, III and IV.
Saavik remains a fan favourite whether it's in Curtis' hands or Alley's but it can be for certain that had the future Cheers star not taken that role then it would not continue to resonate to this day. For many, Saavik IS Kirstie Alley, a legacy on Star Trek that stretches to 40 years and beyond.
Truthfully, I prefer Robin Curtis' Saavik. I thought she was more tender and vulnerable. Also, her attraction to David Marcus, while she still fulfilled a vital role for regenerated Spock, was rendered beautifully. I always felt Kirstie Alley had a sneering face and a chip on her shoulder. I didn't like her Saavik at all and was so glad when the character was recast.
ReplyDeleteIn a way she set the template which Curtis then expanded on. Have to agree on reflection that Curtis had better chemistry with Butrick than Alley.
Delete