Learning Curve

Prodigy back for season two, Strange New Worlds back in June and renewed and Lower Decks also back soon and renewed - what more could you ask for?

How about that Section 31 series?

Not a chance.

The news out of the Star Trek stable this week has all been positive in regards to existing series but coupled withe the unexpected announcement of a Starfleet Academy series to begin filming in 2024.

Academy? Hang on...

Yes, after decades of ifs, buts and maybes, the long fabled, never seen, often promised show is about to become a reality. Touted as far back as 1991, Starfleet Academy nearly became Star Trek VI before becoming a junior novel series as well as an Interplay PC game, graphic novel and finally, over 30 years later a TV show.

I was always under the firm impression that the next show would be Section 31 related but with Michelle Yeoh's stratospheric rise and recent Oscar win is it possible that she's priced herself out of Kurtzman's market for the foreseeable future? With her exit from Discovery now heading towards two years ago will anyone really be engaged enough to want to see the show?

With Discovery's confirmed closure with season five it does feel that the story is coming to an end as are all related avenues from the series that resurrected the franchise on TV. After all the Sonequa Martin-Green vehicle was supposed to run and run but has now been rather unceremoniously axed.

The series did feature, as part of its fourth season, a group of cadets under the tutelage of Sylvia Tilly so there is the hint that actually it could be a spin-off from Discovery and continue that 32nd Century adventure although whether fans would welcome another foray into that time period is questionable at best.

All that's known is from the announcement that we will get a new cast of characters and it is confirmed. This will mean that Star Trek's existence will be maintained with two live action and two animated series as long as they all remain popular for the next two years.

Am I interested in an Academy series? At this time I'm not sure because Prodigy seems to be filling that gap although it is aimed (honestly!) at a younger market with its cast of adolescent characters. Is the Academy series perhaps intended to fill a gap in the teen market where Prodigy leaves off and thus providing a series for every age? 

It is possible and would make sense to provide blanket generational coverage to bring fans through but then there is a part of me that hopes it would be more akin to Picard and Strange New Worlds in its style with a more adult tone and mission statement.

But it does surprise me that Section 31 (apparently still a possibility) has been sidestepped again. Already it's missed the boat thanks to the popularity of Pike, Spock and Number One in Discovery's second season and it feels like it might not even survive to be a filler show should any of the confirmed projects fall short.

Any new content and continuation of the franchise - this will be its fourth live action series in six years - has to be seen as a good thing and that Star Trek is very much alive and a success. Or is this a final roll of the dice? Has the franchise already run its course in this new age and fatigue/desperation is setting in? Have the powers that be realised that Section 31 has been bounced around so long it is indeed dead in the water with this as a rushed alternative to fill a once plugged scheduling gap?

That's a lot of variables to consider and we have a few months to go to really dig into them before we hear sign up for our first term at the Academy.

Enjoyed this article? Why not like and share to spread the word!

Like our page on Facebook 

Follow us on Twitter

Drawn to the Story: IDW's Starfleet Academy

Welcome to Ian Kimmins from the USS Cuchulain group who joins Some Kind of Star Trek for his first solo post today!

Released by IDW over the last few months is Star Trek Starfleet Academy.

The team behind this particular five issue run are Mike Johnson, Ryan Parrot and Derek Charm. Starfleet Academy is in good hands as lead writer Mike Johnson writes the ongoing series. Be warned of spoilers as we take a quick overview and tour of this miniseries.

The story takes place in two different times; 2258 and 2261. We have the characters we all know and love from the alternate universe plus we get to see some quite interesting new ones!

The story starts off with Uhura in 2258 who is following a strange signal in a restricted sector of space and in 2261 our new characters are participating in the Academy Centennial Games.

Issue two pushes the story on and we get some good character revealing scenes for the cadets. Meanwhile Uhura and Kirk continued to investigate the strange signal. There is some good interchanges between the characters and we see the determination that is the hallmark of the future Enterprise crew. 

In issue three Uhura finally finds out where the signal is from and uncovers what happened to the USS Slayton in the Wagner 219 system. I won't go into much detail on this issue as it contains quiet a lot of spoilers there are some standout moments in here. It's also nice to see that our cadets aren't infallible.

Issue four kicks off with the cadets on the wrong end of a nasty space worm! At this stage they've so far behind in the games they decide to slingshot around an anomaly to gain time. The anomaly is located at Wagner 219 and this is where everything kicks up a notch. We get to see Spock's mentoring of Uhura and how he gets her out of a tricky situation. Admiral Marcus even pops in for an appearance!

Finally we come to issue five and the story wraps up a little to easily and the cadets end up with a medal. Although not having them win the games was a nice touch.

While this story was aimed at a slightly younger audience than normal it is a good read for all ages. The story works well even if you aren't familiar with the characters although you will get more from the story if you do. Special praise should go to Derek Charm who's art on the series gives it that lighter and brighter look compared to Tony Shasteen's work on the ongoing series. 

It is a nice alternative to the ongoing series artwork and I liked it. It did remind me a little bit of The Animated Series! While it was a little slow to get going and it was tied up very conveniently-It is worth a read and I for one hope we get to see the cadets again.

Both Mike Johnson and Ryan Parrott do a good job on this series. I'm looking forward to them continuing work on the ongoing series and also the upcoming Klingon story Manifest Destiny. Hopefully we will get to see Derek Charm's art again in the comics as really adds to the enjoyment of the story.

Star Trek: Starfleet Academy is now available from comic book stores and is due for  release in Graphic Novel format on 4th August 2016.

Have you been reading this series? What have you thought to it?

NOW check out and subscribe to our monthly podcast. You can find us on iTunes, Soundcloud and Stitcher by searching "Some Kind of Star Trek". Episode one is live and ready for you to listen!

Live on YouTube
Like our page on Facebook 

Follow us on Twitter

+1 us on Google+

Add us on Tumblr

Join the conversation on Star Trek: Risa